How to Make a Pillow Insert: A DIY Guide for Comfort and Style

Making a pillow insert at home allows for customization, cost savings, and creative freedom.

Whether you want a sewn version for long-term use or a no-sew option for quick projects, this guide covers everything you need to create the perfect pillow insert for any space.

DIY Pillow Insert: Choosing the Right Materials

Before you begin, gather the necessary materials to ensure a well-made pillow insert.

Essential Materials:

• Fabric – Cotton, muslin, or poly-blend fabrics work best.

• Stuffing – Polyfill, down feathers, shredded memory foam, or repurposed fabric scraps.

• Sewing supplies – Thread, needle, pins, scissors, measuring tape.

• Alternative adhesives – Fabric glue, fusible webbing, or iron-on tape for no-sew options.

How to Make a Pillow Insert

Follow these steps to create a simple and functional pillow insert.

Step 1: Measure and Cut Fabric

• Determine the size of your insert by measuring the pillow cover.

• Add one inch to each side to allow for seam allowances.

• Cut two identical fabric squares or rectangles.

Step 2: Sew or Glue the Edges

• For a sewn insert:

  • Place the fabric pieces right sides together.

  • Sew around three sides, leaving one side open.

  • Trim excess fabric and turn the insert inside out.

• For a no-sew insert:

  • Use fabric glue or iron-on tape along three edges.

  • Press firmly and let it dry completely before turning inside out.

DIY Pillow Insert No-Sew Method

A no-sew pillow insert is ideal for quick projects or for those who don’t sew.

Steps for a No-Sew Pillow Insert:

1. Cut two pieces of fabric in the desired size, ensuring they align perfectly for even seams.

2. Apply fabric glue or iron-on tape along the edges, leaving one side open to insert the filling.

3. Press edges together and hold them in place for a few minutes to secure a strong bond.

4. Stuff the pillow insert evenly, making sure to distribute the filling to avoid lumps or uneven texture.

5. Seal the open edge using additional glue or adhesive tape, pressing firmly for a seamless finish.

6. Let the insert set completely before using to ensure durability and prevent accidental opening.

How to Properly Stuff a Pillow Insert

Stuffing is key to achieving the right level of comfort and structure.

Best Practices for Stuffing a Pillow Insert:

• Use small amounts of stuffing at a time to prevent lumpiness and ensure a smooth finish.

• Distribute the filling evenly by fluffing as you go, paying attention to the corners and edges.

• Add extra stuffing for firmness if needed, especially for decorative or support pillows.

• For down or feather inserts, ensure the fabric is tightly woven to prevent feathers from poking out and causing discomfort.

• Rotate and press the insert once fully stuffed to even out any uneven areas and maintain a plush, full look.

Tips for Long-Lasting Pillow Inserts

• Use high-quality filling to maintain shape and longevity, reducing the need for frequent replacements.

• Choose durable fabric that withstands wear and washing, ensuring extended use without fraying or tearing.

• Wash periodically following care instructions to keep the insert fresh and free from dust or allergens.

• Fluff regularly to maintain the pillow’s shape and prevent flat spots, keeping it comfortable and supportive.

A well-made pillow insert enhances comfort and aesthetics when paired with a high-quality mattress. A Puffy Lux Mattress provides exceptional back support, complementing the plush feel of your DIY pillows.

Conclusion

Creating your own pillow insert is a simple, cost-effective way to enhance home decor.

Whether you opt for a sewn or no-sew version, choosing the right materials and stuffing technique ensures comfort and durability.

With the right approach, your custom-made pillow insert will provide support and style for years to come.