HomeLux Comfort
What Is a Tooth Fairy Pillow? A Fun Tradition for Kids
Lux Comfort

What Is a Tooth Fairy Pillow? A Fun Tradition for Kids

From Puffy Editorial Team
Last updated on: Jan 31, 2025 | 5 min read
What Is a Tooth Fairy Pillow? A Fun Tradition for Kids

Key Takeaways

  • A tooth fairy pillow is a small decorative pillow with a pocket designed to hold a lost tooth and the reward left by the tooth fairy.
  • These pillows make the tradition more magical by creating a dedicated space for the exchange, preventing lost teeth or misplaced money.
  • Customization options allow parents and children to personalize their tooth fairy pillow with colors, embroidery, and fun shapes.

Losing a tooth is a big milestone for kids, and the tooth fairy tradition makes the experience even more special. But what happens when a tiny tooth gets lost under a big pillow? That’s where a tooth fairy pillow comes in.

These charming little pillows provide a dedicated place to store lost teeth and receive a special gift in return. Let’s explore what a tooth fairy pillow is, how it adds magic to the tradition, and how you can make one yourself.

What Is a Tooth Fairy Pillow?

A tooth fairy pillow is a small, specially designed pillow with a pocket to hold a child’s lost tooth. Instead of tucking the tooth under a regular pillow, where it can get lost or be difficult for the tooth fairy to find, a tooth fairy pillow makes the exchange simple and fun.

Benefits of a Tooth Fairy Pillow

  • Prevents lost teeth and money: A dedicated pocket keeps everything in place.

  • Adds excitement to the tradition: A fun design enhances the experience.

  • Easier for parents: No more fumbling under the child’s head to make the swap.

  • A cherished keepsake: Some kids love keeping their pillow long after they’ve lost their last tooth.

What to Put Under the Pillow From the Tooth Fairy

Many parents wonder what they should leave in exchange for a lost tooth. While money is the most common gift, there are plenty of creative alternatives to make the tradition even more exciting.

Fun Gift Ideas

  • Money: Coins or dollar bills, sometimes with a sprinkle of fairy dust (glitter) for extra magic.

  • Small toys: Mini figurines, stickers, or tiny trinkets can be exciting surprises.

  • Notes from the tooth fairy: A handwritten message congratulating the child on their lost tooth.

  • Fairy accessories: A tiny wand, wings, or a little pouch labeled “Tooth Fairy Treasure.”

  • Book about the tooth fairy: A fun story to read at bedtime.

What Does the Tooth Fairy Leave Under Your Pillow?

Each family puts their own unique spin on the tooth fairy tradition, but here are some of the most popular items left by the tooth fairy:

Common Tooth Fairy Gifts

  1. Dollar bills – Some parents fold them into creative shapes like stars or hearts.

  2. Glitter coins – Sprinkling a little glitter on coins makes them feel magical.

  3. Tiny letters – A note written in a “fairy-sized” font congratulating the child.

  4. Fairy dust – A light sprinkle of glitter on the pillow to show that the tooth fairy visited.

  5. Healthy snacks – A small pack of dried fruit or nuts to encourage healthy habits.

  6. Certificates – Some parents print or write out a “Lost Tooth Certificate” for their child.

Pairing a magical experience with a comfortable mattress like a Puffy Lux Mattress can make bedtime something to look forward to, ensuring kids rest peacefully while awaiting their tooth fairy visit.

How Does the Tooth Fairy Get Under Your Pillow?

One of the biggest mysteries for kids is how the tooth fairy manages to sneak under their pillow without waking them up. Parents have come up with creative ways to make the magic feel real.

Fun Tooth Fairy Stories

  • The fairy uses magic: She sprinkles fairy dust to put children into a deep sleep while she works.

  • She’s as light as a feather: Fairies are so tiny and gentle that they never make a sound.

  • She waits until you’re in a deep sleep: Parents can tell kids that the fairy can sense when they’re dreaming and only comes then.

  • She flies through a fairy door: Some families set up a tiny fairy door in the bedroom where the tooth fairy enters and exits.

  • She leaves a magical trail: Some parents sprinkle a bit of glitter on the windowsill to show where the fairy flew in and out.

Fun Ways to Make the Tooth Fairy Visit Special

Parents can add extra magic to the tooth fairy experience by making the visit feel even more enchanting.

Creative Ideas to Enhance the Tradition

  • Leave tiny footprints: Use a small brush and flour or glitter to create tiny “fairy footprints” on the nightstand.

  • Use glow-in-the-dark notes: Write a special message from the tooth fairy that glows when the lights go out.

  • Create a fairy door: Set up a small decorative fairy door on the wall where the tooth fairy “enters.”

  • Make a tooth fairy receipt: Some parents create tiny “official receipts” for lost teeth, signed by the tooth fairy.

  • Add a special fairy ringtone: Play soft chimes or a fairy sound effect on your phone while your child is sleeping to create an extra magical moment.

Conclusion

A tooth fairy pillow makes the tradition of losing a tooth even more magical by providing a special place for the tooth and reward.

Whether bought or handmade, these pillows add fun, excitement, and convenience to the experience.

By incorporating creative elements and personal touches, parents can keep the magic alive and create lasting memories for their children.

Get Your Puffy Lux Mattress
$1,350 in savings
Transform your comfort with the Puffy Lux.
Relax into award-winning comfort with this hybrid mattress:
  • 8 layers of cloudlike luxury.
  • Medium-plush feel.
  • Gel-infused cooling.
  • 101-night sleep trial.
SHOP PUFFY LUX

Shop the Award-Winning Puffy Collection

puffy mattresss

Choose Your Award-Winning Mattress

Experience the cloudlike comfort and support of our hybrid and memory foam mattresses.

  • 4 luxury mattresses
  • All sleeper types
  • Made in the USA

Prices start from $499

SHOP MATTRESSES
puffy bed frame

Customize Your Comfort With a Bed Frame

Upgrade your sleep with our stylish and supportive bed frames, bases, and foundations.

  • Support for all mattresses
  • Adjustable comfort options
  • Quick and easy setup

Prices start from $152

SHOP BED FRAMES
puffy beddings

Elevate Your Sleep With Luxury Bedding

Add luxury to bedtime with our silky soft sheets, protectors, blankets, and more.

  • Premium materials
  • Contemporary style
  • Ultra-soft comfort

Prices start from $59

SHOP BEDDING

Puffy Is Ranked America’s #1
Luxury Mattress

Hear from
12,000+
satisfied Puffy sleepers about why they give our award-winning comfort 5 stars.

READ PUFFY MATTRESS REVIEWS

Find Official Puffy
Mattress Stores Near You

Try out the cloudlike comfort of the luxury Puffy mattress collection before you buy at our partner stores across the USA.

FIND A MATTRESS STORE NEAR YOU
SIGN UP FOR EXCLUSIVE SAVINGS.
Get special offers, product news,
and sleep tips straight to your inbox.
Save $1,425 when you buy any Puffy mattress. Verify your eligibility for our: