02D24E7D-67D3-4337-92AC-2BC3D8171DB7 Yes A72A1DAE-6539-461D-A000-4179652AA390
April Sale: $1,350 in savings
0 1
Copy Discount Code

Code copied successfully.

Home Lux Comfort
How to Make Crib Mattress Softer: A Complete Guide for Fussy Sleepers

How to Make Crib Mattress Softer: A Complete Guide for Fussy Sleepers

How to Make Crib Mattress Softer: A Complete Guide for Fussy Sleepers

Hey, parents! Let's talk about something soft, literally. Has your little one turned into a mini mattress critic? Are they fussy and irritable, pointing tiny fingers of blame at their hard crib mattress?

Before you stress about transitioning them to a new bed or, worse, consider a midnight drive to lull them to sleep, this guide is for you. We're diving deep into the soft and fluffy world of making a crib mattress softer, ensuring your little one’s comfort while also keeping safety top-of-mind.

Table of Contents

How to Make a Crib Mattress Softer

Alright, so your infant isn't settling well on their new mattress, and you want to make it cozier. Here’s how:

1. Mattress Toppers

These are an instant fix. A soft, breathable mattress topper can add that extra layer of plush comfort.

2. Layer It Up

Layering is not just a fashion statement; it's a bedding one too. Use multiple fitted sheets or a soft quilted sheet to add softness.

3. Break It In

This might sound odd, but you can break in a mattress just like a new pair of shoes. Simply applying gentle pressure regularly can help soften it up over time. But remember, don't overdo it - crib mattresses are designed to be firm for safety reasons.

How to Make Crib Mattress Softer for Toddler

Toddlers are a whole different ball game. They have opinions, and they are not afraid to share them. So, what do you do when your toddler complains about their bed?

1. Try Flipping It

Some crib mattresses are dual-sided, with one side softer than the other. Flip it and see if that does the trick.

2. Upgrade the Padding

For toddlers, it’s generally safer to add a little more padding. A quilted mattress protector can add just the right amount of cushiness.

3. Look into Modular Designs

Some mattresses come with removable layers. These can be rearranged to suit your toddler’s evolving preferences. If your mattress has this feature, experiment a little.

The Role of Crib Mattress Covers

Don't underestimate the power of a good mattress cover. A plush, organic cotton cover can work wonders in making a mattress feel softer to the touch.

Zippered Covers

Opt for a zippered cover that encloses the entire mattress, offering an added layer of comfort.

Textured Fabric Choices

Consider covers made from velour or minky fabric. The texture itself can provide a softer feel.

Check out Puffy mattress reviews from real customers and see how we compare with other brands.

Is a Pillowtop a Good Idea?

Pillowtops can certainly add a layer of plush comfort, but they may not be the best choice for infants due to safety concerns around suffocation. For toddlers, however, a well-secured, thin pillowtop could provide that extra softness they desire.

The Don'ts of Softening a Crib Mattress

Before you turn that mattress into a cloud, there are some vital things to avoid.

No Loose Material

Never use loose blankets or quilts under your baby as it poses a suffocation risk.

Skip the Adult Bedding

Adult pillows and mattress toppers are not suitable for a crib mattress. Stick to products specifically designed for cribs.

Beware of Softness Overload

Remember, a little extra softness is okay, but a crib mattress should still maintain a certain level of firmness to be safe.


Parenthood is one big learning curve, and choosing the right mattress comfort level for your little one can be a bit like Goldilocks finding the perfect bed - it takes some trial and error.

Use our store locator to find the closest furniture or mattress store near you and feel the cloudlike comfort of our Puffy Mattress in person.

So whether you're layering it up or considering a high-tech modular design, remember: the ultimate goal is to blend comfort with safety. Here's to sweeter dreams and less fussy mornings (or, let's be real, just getting any sleep at all). Happy nesting!

Choose your Puffy Mattress

article ad savings icon $1,350 in savings

Unlock your ultimate sleep solution with Puffy.

Explore our award-winning Puffy mattress collection with these extra luxury benefits:

  • Award-winning comfort.
  • Lifetime warranty.
  • 101-night sleep trial.
  • Free shipping and returns.
  • 100% made in USA.