Take The Puffy Mattress Quiz
What is your ideal price range?
Who do you share your bed space with?
What build are you?
Do you experience sleeping hot?
What's your comfort preference?
Calculating result...
Arrow left Back ×
2 FREE with every mattress purchase
Puffy Pillow
Puffy Pillow Adjustable and luxuriously plush - our popular cooling pillow has a perfectly soft yet firm feel that provides just the right amount of support.
  • Made in USA
  • Zip-n-wash cover
  • Adjustable height
  • CertiPUR-US® certified memory foam fill
FREE with every mattress purchase
Puffy Mattresses Protector
Puffy Mattress Protector A cozy barrier that protects your mattress against spills, sweat, stains, and damage - it keeps your mattress fresh without compromising your comfort.
  • Waterproof mattress protector
  • Cooling fabric
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Oeko-Tex® Standard 100 Certified
  • Machine washable
FREE with every mattress purchase
Puffy Sheets
Puffy Sheets Our ultra-soft 100% bamboo sheet set has a luxurious silky finish. Naturally breathable and airy, these sheets will help you stay comfortably cool all night.
  • Cooling and airy
  • 100% bamboo
  • Hypoallergenic
  • 300 thread count
  • Oeko-Tex® Standard 100 Certified
Your Puffy Cart 0 Items
Cart is empty
Free shipping and returns
Puffy VS Casper
Puffy VS Casper


Compare Puffy and Casper mattresses side-by-side. Quick Comparison
A good night’s sleep depends on the quality of your mattress, but the mattress-buying process can be confusing. With so many options available, how do you decide which one is the perfect fit for your bedroom? One of the best ways to determine your ideal mattress match is to compare key value points. This comprehensive Puffy vs Casper overview breaks down the features and benefits of each to help you find the mattress of your dreams. Puffy and Casper are both top mattress brands that are currently dominating the online space. In particular, Puffy is a standout for support, comfort, cooling, and other benefits. Here, we break down the differences between the original Puffy Mattress and Casper Original Mattress.
Shop The Mattress
Puffy vs Casper Mattress

How Does Puffy Stack Up?

This quick comparison lays out the key benefits of each mattress.
Starting Price (Queen) $949$1,249 $1,095
Shipping 2 - 5 Business Days 8 - 11 Business Days
Mattress Trial 101 Nights 100 Nights
Warranty Lifetime Warranty 10-Year Limited Warranty
Made in USA USA
2 Free Pillows
Free Mattress Protector
Free Sheets
Free Shipping & Returns
Prices last updated 08/11/2021 and are subject to change at any time.

Start Your 101-Night Sleep Trial Today

Take your time getting comfy. Whether it’s a new mattress, blanket, or dog bed, you can try all Puffy products risk-free for 101 nights. Shop The Mattress

Mattress Reviews

Over 10,000 5-Star Reviews! See how real customers compare Puffy vs Casper.
Love the mattress

Love the mattress, we returned our Casper “Wave” and purchased this one.

- William S.

Better than Casper!

We love our Puffy mattress! We bought a Casper for our cabin last year and liked it. Then we needed a new mattress at home and decided to try a new brand. We are so glad we did!

- Barbara L.

Feels Puffy

My girlfriend and I love this mattress. It seriously feels 10 times better than the Casper we slept on.

- Mark P.

I won with Puffy

So my husband and I were at odds over different mattresses. He wanted a Casper and I wanted a Puffy, I told him we get a Casper and don’t love it then we are getting a Cal King Puffy. Guess what we are sleeping on now? He even stopped snoring most nights ;)

- Elias C.

Two paws up!

First time with a memory foam, love it. Reviewed against Casper, T&N, and others, Puffy’s definitely the superior brand!

- Charles K.

Finally found a great mattress for chronic neck and back pain!

I tried Casper, Wink, and a couple others including expensive latex, nothing worked for my bad neck and back. Glad to finally wake up without pain!

- Karen G.

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Firmness

How firm is the mattress?

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Firmness

Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Mattress is medium-firm comfort at its best. The firmness level sits between 6 to 8 on the firmness scale, which is suitable for all types of sleepers. Puffy’s unique firmness level is what gives the mattress its signature cloud-like feel. Medium-firm is especially suitable for side sleepers who require additional contouring support for their hips and shoulders.

Casper Original

Casper Original is a medium-firm mattress with a soft foam top layer. Casper’s firmness level is great for back and combination sleepers.
Conclusion: Mattress firmness can be a matter of preference, but it’s hard to go wrong with medium-firm. Because these mattresses are neither too firm nor too soft, you get the best of both worlds. Puffy is widely considered a true medium-firm mattress, so it’s designed to provide the ideal level of support and comfort.

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Construction

How is the mattress constructed?

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Construction

Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Mattress is a gel-infused, blended memory foam mattress. It has a 5-layer construction, and all foams are CertiPUR-US® Certified, which means they’re free of harmful chemical compounds. Here are the key features and functions of each layer in the Puffy Mattress.
  • The Stain-Resistant Cloud Cover is hypoallergenic, which makes it safe for sensitive sleepers. Zip-n-wash the cover at home to easily remove dirt and germs.
  • The 2-inch, gel-infused Cooling Cloud™ Foam layer is high-density and cool to the touch. It is infused with cooling gel to manage temperature fluctuations and deliver an uninterrupted night’s sleep.
  • The 2-inch Climate Comfort™ Foam layer combines advanced breathability with pressure-relieving properties to alleviate pain from muscles and joints.
  • The 6-inch Firm Core Support Foam layer is designed to support and stabilize the mattress and keep your spine aligned. This polyurethane base layer is developed with Variable Pressure Foaming (VPF) technology, making the Puffy a durable and eco-friendly choice.
  • The Grip Base Cover sits perfectly on any bed frame and helps the mattress stay put, even if you toss and turn at night.

Casper Original

The Casper Original memory foam mattress has three layers. Here’s a breakdown of each:
  • The AirScape™ foam layer is designed to increase airflow and relieve pressure.
  • The Zoned Support™ is a layer of memory foam with three ergonomic zones for spinal alignment.
  • The Durable Base is designed to prevent sinking and sagging.

Conclusion: To ensure you’re investing in the best mattress for optimal rest, it’s essential to research its construction and understand the function of each layer. Because the Puffy Mattress is a 5-layer construction, it is designed to suit a variety of sleepers and adapt to all sleeping positions. In particular, Puffy provides targeted support, manages temperature fluctuations, and offers advanced breathability.

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Comfort

Does the mattress have unique comfort features?

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Comfort

Puffy Mattress

Puffy is famous for its signature, cloud-like feel, and has been ranked Best Mattress 2022. The Cooling Cloud™ Foam layer sets it apart from competitors in terms of delivering bespoke comfort. In addition to the Puffy Mattress, customers can also choose between two other models, the Puffy Lux Hybrid and the Puffy Royal Hybrid. Each model has distinctive features and is designed to offer full-body support with exceptional cooling capabilities. Puffy has also snagged numerous awards, including Best Mattress 2022.

Casper Original

The Casper Original features the AirScape™ foam layer that’s designed to increase airflow and circulates air so that you wake up feeling refreshed.
Conclusion: At the end of the day, comfort reigns supreme. Both mattresses offer unique features that can help you get a good night’s rest. But with the Puffy Mattress, you can experience cloud-like comfort.

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Support

Does the mattress offer back and body support?

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Support

Puffy Mattress

The Puffy Mattress has excellent contouring capabilities with medium-firm support, thanks to its high-density memory foam formulation. The Climate Comfort™ Foam layer offers advanced breathability and is designed to support the body by keeping the spine aligned. Regardless of your preferred sleeping position, the Puffy Mattress is specially engineered to support your body and eliminate pressure points. Puffy has also been recognized for its pressure-relieving capabilities with accolades, such as Best Mattress for Side Sleepers with Back Pain 2022 and Best Mattress for Pressure Relief 2022.

Casper Original

The Casper Original features a Zoned Support™ layer that’s designed to provide targeted support for spinal alignment. Conclusion: To gain the restorative benefits of a good night’s sleep, it’s essential to invest in a mattress that supports your joints and muscles. The Puffy Mattress has three contouring foam layers that cradle your body just right and can offer support to your hips, back, and shoulders.

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Warranty

How long does the warranty last?

Puffy vs Casper Mattress: Warranty

Puffy Mattress

Puffy offers a free lifetime warranty on all products, including mattresses, bedding, bed frames, and even the dog bed. For as long as customers use Puffy’s products, they’re protected by a risk-free lifetime warranty. In case of any defects, your Puffy Mattress will be replaced with a new one free of charge.

Casper Original

The Casper Original is covered by a 10-year limited warranty. Unlike Puffy, Casper’s warranty differs from product to product. While Casper offers customers a 10-year limited warranty on mattresses, select products such as pillows, sheets, blankets, duvets, and protectors are backed by a 1-year limited warranty.
Conclusion: A new mattress can be a significant investment, but a risk-free warranty can offer you some peace of mind. To ensure that your purchase is protected, it’s important to always choose products with the most extended warranty period.

Mattress Financing With Klarna Payment Method

Pay as low as $50/mo for a Puffy Mattress
Mattress financing as low as 0% APR
Apply and pre-qualify in minutes
Pay in up to 36 months
Learn More

The Puffy Advantage

Can’t decide between Puffy vs Casper? Here’s why Puffy is ranked best mattress:

  • All Puffy products have a lifetime warranty
  • You get to trial any product for 101 nights
  • You get free shipping* and returns
* Shipping fees apply to AK and HI. Shop The Mattress


  • What is the most comfortable mattress, Puffy or Casper?

    The Puffy Mattress has a distinctive foam formulation that feels like sleeping on a cloud. The Cooling Cloud™ Foam layer is specifically designed to mold and cradle your body and relieve pressure points, while the Climate Comfort™ Foam layer manages temperature fluctuations to ensure you get an uninterrupted night’s sleep.
  • Which mattress is better for hot sleepers?

    Both mattresses include layers that are designed to keep you cool, but Puffy’s Climate Comfort™ and Cooling Cloud™ foams offer advanced breathability for enhanced cooling. Not only does it keep you cool on warm nights, but it also regulates temperature so that you’re comfortable on chillier nights.
  • Which mattress is better for side sleepers, Puffy or Casper?

    A medium-firm mattress is a great choice for side sleepers who require additional contouring support for their hips and shoulders. The Puffy Mattress is a true medium-firm mattress that’s designed to align the spine, relieve pressure points, and cradle the body just right. The Casper Original is also a medium-firm mattress that includes a Zoned Support™ layer to encourage proper spinal alignment.
  • How long does a Puffy Mattress last?

    The lifespan of a mattress can vary and largely depends on how well you take care of it. With proper care and maintenance, the Puffy Mattress can last twice as long as a regular mattress.
  • What is the cover on the Puffy Mattress made of?

    The Stain-Resistant Cloud Cover is Oeko-Tex® Standard 100 Certified, which means it’s sourced from premium providers and has the highest certification standards to ensure it’s free from chemical substances. The cover is hypoallergenic and you can easily zip-n-wash it at home to remove dirt and germs.