Official Puffy vs Casper Mattress Comparison
choose Puffy.
 | Casper | |
|---|---|---|
| Savings | ||
| Savings | $1,350 Free luxury pillows & sleep masks included. $1,350 MORE IN SAVINGS | 0% |
| Warranty | ||
| Warranty | Lifetime Warranty | 10-Year Limited Warranty |
| Sleep Trial | ||
| Sleep Trial | 101 Nights | 100 Nights |
| Weight | ||
| Weight | 34 lbs 28% LIGHTER | 47 lbs |
| Made in USA | ||
| Made in USA | ||
| 2 Free Pillows | ||
| 2 Free Pillows | ||
| 2 Free Sleep Masks* | ||
| 2 Free Sleep Masks* | ||
| Free Nationwide Shipping & Returns | ||
| Free Nationwide Shipping & Returns | ||
*Twin & twin XL mattresses include 1 sleep mask.
| Casper | |
|---|---|---|
| Back Support | ||
| Back Support | 9.4 | 7.6 |
| Sleeping Cool | ||
| Sleeping Cool | 9.8 | 8.1 |
| Side Sleepers | ||
| Side Sleepers | 9.8 | 8.2 |
| Stomach Sleepers | ||
| Stomach Sleepers | 9.6 | 7.7 |
| Comfort | ||
| Comfort | 7.7 | |
America’s Most
Award-Winning Mattress
Foam Mattress 2025
Forbes Vetted 2024
Back Pain 2025
Pressure Relief
2025
Firmness
Puffy Cloud Mattress
The Puffy Cloud Mattress is medium-firm comfort at its best. The firmness level sits between 6 to 8 on the firmness scale, which is suitable for all types of sleepers.
Puffy's unique firmness level is what gives the mattress its signature cloudlike feel. Medium-firm is especially suitable for side sleepers who require additional contouring support for their hips and shoulders.
Casper One Foam Mattress
The Casper One Foam Mattress is a medium-firm mattress with a soft knitted top layer. Casper's firmness level is great for back and stomach sleepers.
Mattress firmness can be a matter of preference, but it's hard to go wrong with medium-firm. Because these mattresses are neither too firm nor too soft, you get the best of both worlds. Puffy is widely considered a true medium-firm mattress, so it's designed to provide the ideal level of support and comfort, making it an ideal choice for all sleeper types.
Construction
Puffy Cloud Mattress
The Puffy Cloud Mattress is a gel-infused, memory foam mattress, with a responsive 6-layer construction that is designed to provide cooling comfort and relieve pain and pressure. All foams are CertiPUR-US® certified, which means they're free of harmful chemical compounds. Here are the key features and functions of each layer in the Puffy Cloud Mattress.
- The Cool Touch Cloud Cover features a patented cloud design. The cover is knitted with cooling yarns, adding a cool-to-the-touch sensation, making the mattress feel refreshing and cloudlike.
- The Climate Fiber Layer is made of heat-resistant fibers that are soft and add cushioning. It also helps enhance airflow.
- The 2-inch, gel-infused Cooling Cloud™ Foam layer is high-density and disperses heat away from the body. It is infused with cooling gel to manage temperature fluctuations and deliver an uninterrupted night's sleep while maximizing comfort by cradling muscles and joints.
- The 2-inch Cloud Comfort Pressure-Relief Foam layer features advanced pressure-relieving properties to align the back and provide optimal support while you sleep.
- The 6-inch Firm Core Support Foam layer is designed to support and stabilize the mattress and keep your back aligned. This high-density foam layer also isolates motion, so there's no movement transfer or bounce that could disturb continuous sleep.
- The Grip Base Cover sits perfectly on any bed frame and helps the mattress stay put, even if you toss and turn at night.
Nectar Premier Mattress
The Casper One Foam memory foam mattress has four layers. Here's a breakdown of each:
- The Cozy Cover is a soft, airy knitted top layer.
- The Breathe Flex Foam layer is designed to be responsive and breathable.
- The Align Memory Foam layer is pressure-relieving and cradles your body.
- The Casper Core layer is the thick bottom layer.
To ensure you're investing in the best mattress for optimal rest, it's essential to research its construction and understand the function of each layer. As the Puffy Cloud Mattress has a 6-layer construction, it is designed to suit a variety of sleepers and adapt to all sleeping positions. In particular, Puffy provides targeted support, manages temperature fluctuations, and offers advanced breathability.
Comfort
Puffy Cloud Mattress
Casper One Foam Mattress
The Casper One Foam features the Breathe Flex Foam layer that's designed to relieve pressure and enhance airflow, so you wake up feeling refreshed.
At the end of the day, comfort reigns supreme. Both mattresses offer unique features that can help you get a good night's rest. But with the Puffy Cloud Mattress, you can experience cloudlike comfort.
Support
Puffy Cloud Mattress
The Puffy Cloud Mattress has excellent contouring capabilities with medium-firm support, thanks to its high-density memory foam formulation. The Cloud Comfort Pressure-Relief Foam layer is designed to support the body by keeping the back aligned. Regardless of your preferred sleeping position, the Puffy Cloud Mattress is specially engineered to support your body and help eliminate pressure points and back pain. Puffy has also been recognized for its pressure-relieving capabilities with accolades, such as Best Mattress for Back Pain 2025 and Best Mattress for Pressure Relief 2025.
Casper One Foam Mattress
The Casper One Foam features the Align Memory Foam layer that's designed to relieve pressure and cradle your body.
To gain the restorative benefits of a good night's sleep, it's essential to invest in a mattress that supports your joints and muscles. The Puffy Cloud Mattress has three high-density contouring foam layers that cradle your body and can offer support to your hips, back, and shoulders.
Warranty
Puffy Cloud Mattress
Casper One Foam Mattress
The Casper One Foam Mattress is covered by a 10-year limited warranty. Unlike Puffy, Casper's warranty differs from product to product. While Casper offers customers a 10-year limited warranty on mattresses, select products such as pillows, sheets, blankets, duvets, and protectors are backed by a 1-year limited warranty.
A new mattress can be a significant investment, but a risk-free warranty can offer you some peace of mind. To ensure that your purchase is protected, it's important to always choose products with the most extended warranty period.
Contact Us 7 Days a Week
for Best-in-Class Support
with a specialist.
Let's chat.
email.
8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m. PST Saturday-Sunday
Special Offers
tips straight to your inbox.