Official Puffy vs Saatva Mattress Comparison
choose Puffy.
 | Saatva | |
|---|---|---|
| Savings | ||
| Savings | $1,350 Includes free Luxury Pillows. $1,350 MORE IN SAVINGS | $0 |
| Starting Price | ||
| Starting Price | $499 $1,849 | $1,399 |
| Shipping | ||
| Shipping | 1 - 2 Business Days | 9 - 21 Days |
| Warranty | ||
| Warranty | Lifetime Warranty You pay nothing | Lifetime Warranty with Processing Fees |
| Weight | ||
| Weight | 34 lbs 62% LIGHTER | 90 lbs (11.5" Model) |
| Made in USA | ||
| Made in USA | ||
| 2 Free Pillows | ||
| 2 Free Pillows | ||
| Free Nationwide Shipping & Returns | ||
| Free Nationwide Shipping & Returns | ||
| Saatva | |
|---|---|---|
| Back Support | ||
| Back Support | 9.4 | 8.3 |
| Sleeping Cool | ||
| Sleeping Cool | 9.8 | 8.2 |
| Side Sleepers | ||
| Side Sleepers | 9.8 | 7.9 |
| Stomach Sleepers | ||
| Stomach Sleepers | 9.6 | 8.4 |
| Comfort | ||
| Comfort | 7.9 | |
America’s Most
Award-Winning Mattress
Foam Mattress 2025
Forbes Vetted 2024
Back Pain 2025
Pressure Relief
2025
Firmness
Puffy Cloud Mattress
The Puffy Cloud Mattress provides medium-firm comfort that sits between 6 to 8 on the firmness scale. This firmness level is suitable for all types of sleepers and is especially ideal for side sleepers who require additional contouring support for their hips and shoulders. The mattress is neither too firm nor too soft. This unique firmness level is the reason why Puffy Cloud Mattress feels like “sleeping on a cloud.”
Saatva Classic Mattress
The Saatva Classic Mattress is available in three firmness options: plush soft, medium-firm, and firm. The most popular is the medium-firm option, which sits between 5 to 7 on the firmness scale.
Ultimately, mattress firmness comes down to preference, but medium-firm is typically a safe bet for most people because it suits all sleeping positions. Puffy is widely considered a true medium-firm mattress that provides the ideal combination of support and comfort.
Construction
Puffy Cloud Mattress
The original Puffy Cloud Mattress is a gel-infused memory foam mattress constructed with six layers. All foam layers are CertiPUR-US® certified, which means they're free of harmful chemical compounds. The Puffy Cloud Mattress is designed to provide proper body support and optimal cooling.
Here are the key features and functions of each layer:
- The Cool Touch Cloud Cover is knitted with cooling yarns, which makes the Puffy Cloud the ideal choice for sleepers who enjoy a mattress with a cool-to-the-touch and refreshing feel. The cover features a patented cloud design.
- The Climate Fiber Layer functions as an extra comfort layer. Designed with heat-resistant fibers, the layer is soft and also encourages airflow and breathability, so you can sleep cool and comfortable.
- The 2-inch Cooling Cloud™ Foam layer is infused with cooling gel to disperse heat away from your body. It is a high-density foam that is adaptive and ensures a maximum level of comfort in every sleeping position, cradling muscles and joints.
- The 2-inch Cloud Comfort Pressure-Relief Foam has pressure-relieving properties that are designed to offer relief to your muscles and joints and align your back.
- The 6-inch Firm Core Support Foam layer is a highly adaptive and supportive layer that is specially designed to keep your back aligned and stabilize the mattress. By absorbing motion and therefore eliminating bounce and disturbance, this high-density foam helps you experience uninterrupted sleep, all night long. Another advantage of this layer is that the Puffy Cloud Mattress works on all surfaces and bed frames.
- The Grip Base Cover layer sits perfectly on any style of bed frame and won't slip or slide.
Saatva Classic Mattress
The Saatva Classic Mattress is closer in construction to a traditional innerspring mattress. It is made with two layers of coils, a memory foam layer, a polyfoam layer, and a Euro-top cover. Here's a breakdown of the main features of each layer:
- An organic cotton Euro-top cover
- An active wire and a memory foam layer
- A layer of 14.5-gauge (thickness) pocketed coils
- A base layer of 13-gauge (thickness) support coils
- A foam encasement around the mattress
When comparing different mattress options, it's essential to consider the construction to ensure you're getting the most out of your purchase. As the Puffy Cloud is constructed with three cooling foam layers as well as a cool-to-the-touch cover and cooling fiber layer, it is designed to suit a wide variety of sleepers and perfectly adapts to all sleeping positions, as well as helping you sleep in a breathable, refreshing environment.
Comfort
Puffy Cloud Mattress
The Puffy Cloud Mattress is famous for its signature, cloudlike feel. Its Cloud Comfort Pressure-Relief and Cooling Cloud™ layers set it apart from competitors in terms of delivering unparalleled comfort.
In addition to the original Puffy Cloud Mattress, customers can also choose between three hybrid mattress models: the Puffy Lux, Puffy Royal, and Puffy Monarch. Each mattress model offers a unique level of comfort and is designed to offer full-body support, back pain relief, and exceptional cooling capabilities.
Puffy has also claimed the first-place spot in numerous best mattress award categories, including Best Mattress 2025.
Saatva Classic Mattress
The coils within the Saatva Classic Mattress layers offer a good balance of support and comfort, but feel like a traditional innerspring mattress with bounce. Generally, spring mattresses tend to be less durable and lack the uniform comfort that memory foam provides.
The comfort of a mattress is paramount, and both mattresses offer unique features for a good night's rest. But what says comfort better than the consistently cloudlike feel and all-around responsiveness of a memory foam mattress? With Puffy, you can experience life-changing sleep every single night.
Support
Puffy Cloud Mattress
Thanks to its high-density memory foam formulation, the Puffy Cloud Mattress has contouring capabilities that cradle the body with a medium-firm comfort feel.
Puffy's Cloud Comfort Pressure-Relief Foam layer is specially designed to keep your back aligned, support your body, and eliminate pressure points throughout the night. The Puffy Cloud Mattress has also been awarded the Best Mattress for Pressure Relief 2025 and Best Foam Mattress for Back Sleepers 2025 in recognition of its superior back and body support capabilities.
Saatva Classic Mattress
The Saatva Classic Mattress has two layers of coils, which come in varying degrees of thickness known as gauge. A lower gauge number typically means that a mattress is more supportive. The coils in the Saatva Classic Mattress have a 13 gauge in the lower support layer and a 14.5 gauge in the top coil layer, making it a durable and supportive mattress choice.
To ensure that you enjoy uninterrupted sleep and wake up feeling well-rested, it's important to invest in a mattress that provides pressure relief and contours to your body. Since the Puffy Cloud Mattress has three contouring foam layers, it can cradle the body to your exact profile and offer the right amount of support to your lower back and hips.
Warranty
Puffy Cloud Mattress
Puffy offers a free lifetime warranty on all products, whether it's mattresses, bed frames, or bedroom accessories. For as long as customers own a Puffy product, they're protected by a lifetime warranty. In case of any defects, your Puffy Cloud Mattress will be replaced with a brand-new one free of charge.
Saatva Classic Mattress
Saatva offers customers a Friends for Life warranty program. For the first two years, Saatva will replace a defective mattress with a brand-new one. After that point, the company will recover and repair the existing mattress for a processing fee.
A new mattress can be a significant investment, but a risk-free warranty can offer you some peace of mind. To ensure that your investment lasts and is as risk-free as possible, be sure to always pick the most extended warranty period with the best customer benefits. Puffy offers a lifetime warranty where all product replacements are always free of charge, whereas Saatva charges a processing fee for mattress repairs and replacements after a certain period of time.
Contact Us 7 Days a Week
for Best-in-Class Support
with a specialist.
Let's chat.
email.
8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m. PST Saturday-Sunday
Special Offers
tips straight to your inbox.